EXIT STRATEGY - Ryan Potter

The debut YA novel by Ryan Potter.

Old Blog

Writing Mechanics v. Creativity

Posted on October 9, 2009 at 4:30 PM

Nathan Bransford had a great post a few days ago. He asked a simple question: How important is creativity over craft? Well, that one simple question has generated 200+ comments to date, a healthy number even for Nathan's popular blog. Obviously, then, this issue is a hot one among writers.


Now, I could take the easy way out (many who commented did) and say, Well, it's both, of course!


But it isn't both. At least for me it isn't.  


Find the story and write it the way you see fit. There. That's my one-sentence defense of creativity. Seriously. If the writing rules you learned in school get in the way of how you want to tell a story, then it's time to throw the grammar book out the window. Creativity sets your story apart from all the others. Without it, you have nothing.


Look, I have no clue what  dangling modifiers and past participles are. And you know what? I really don't care. Writing is a feeling as well as a process. Writers (and readers) know when something's wrong with the writing. It's a sense that builds and improves over time. The more you read and write, the stronger that sense - that feeling - becomes. I think you unconsciously learn the rules of grammar that way. To put it another way, reading and writing are the only two grammar classes you'll ever need.


As for the meaning of dangling modifiers and past participles, I'll let the grammar purists obsess over those.


In the meantime, I'll be reading a great novel and writing what I want to write.


RP 

Categories: Writing, Publishing

Post a Comment

Oops

  • Oops, you forgot something.
Already a member? Sign In

1 Comment

Reply Karen Simpson
09:21 AM on October 10, 2009
Amen, Preach LOL .... For the longest time in my critique group I was told over and over again that I wouldn't get published because I didn't know how to do such and such and so and so. Lord knows I'm a terrible speller and I still struggle with commas ect, But I just put my head down and wrote the story that I had and found others to help me with the editing because I knew that wasn't my strength and never will be. although it has gotten better with practice. Anyway, now I'm about to be published and they are not. Creativity is everything in writing. A powerful story told well trumps everything.